GGSH’s Weekly GSTAT Docket #02 | 13 Nov 2026
GSTAT Docket #02: wrong respondent on the portal, uncured registry defects, ITC under the wrong tax head, a Section 129 penalty beyond the notice and GIDC leasehold rights
Every week, GSTAT Docket brings you five GST Appellate Tribunal decisions from benches across India: properly cited, simplified, with who appealed, who won, and our take on what each one changes for your next appeal. This second edition covers Cases 06 to 10, with a procedural lens: what happens when the portal entry is wrong, when Registry defects are ignored, when ITC sits under the wrong head, and when a penalty goes beyond the notice.
Our GAVEL picks this week
- Penalty above the notice? Not even as a ‘clerical error’. → Case 09
- SLP dismissed, review pending? The HC ruling still binds. → Case 10
Inside this edition
- Wrong respondent on the portal is a curable defect (In favour of Taxpayer)
- Uncured registry defects: Department’s appeal dismissed (In favour of Taxpayer)
- ITC under wrong tax head: clerical-error plea fails (In favour of Revenue)
- Sec 129 penalty set aside: no hearing, beyond SCN (In favour of Taxpayer)
- No GST on assignment of GIDC leasehold rights (In favour of Taxpayer)
Case 06: Wrong respondent selected on GSTAT portal is a curable defect
In favour of Taxpayer | Interlocutory Application by Taxpayer
Citation
Crown Soaps v. Principal Commissioner, CGST, Kolhapur & Ors.
GSTAT Pune | 2026 (10) TMI 372
INTL. APPL/1/PUN/2026 in APL/12/PUN/2026 | Date: 01.10.2026
Facts
The appellant inadvertently selected the wrong respondent on the GSTAT portal.
- Selected: Principal Commissioner, CGST, Kolhapur
- Correct authority: Commissioner of State Tax, Maharashtra
The appeal memorandum and impugned order named the correct State authority; only the portal entry was wrong.
Issue Involved
Can the respondent’s name be corrected after registration of the appeal?
Taxpayer Submissions
The appellant sought permission to replace the wrongly selected respondent with the correct State tax authority.
Department’s Submissions
No appearance. The wrongly impleaded respondent did not appear.
Tribunal Analysis
The error was not fatal to the appeal.
- Rule 26 permits rectification of clerical errors through the Registrar.
- Rule 32(1) allows a defective Form GST APL-05 to be accepted for sufficient cause, with up to 30 days to rectify defects.
- The appellant had not availed the Rule 26 remedy before registration.
- The portal has no facility to correct a respondent’s name after registration, so corrected documents had to be re-uploaded.
Final Order
The application was allowed. The Tribunal directed:
- the appellant to substitute the correct respondent and upload the corrected Form GST APL-05 and appeal memorandum;
- the Registrar, GSTAT Pune Bench, to take up correction of the portal record with NIC.
Our Take
The portal entry is usually checked last, and that is where errors creep in. Match the respondent and order details against the impugned order before you submit.
- Seek rectification under Rule 26 before the respondent appears; no ex-parte amendment is allowed after that.
- If the appeal is already registered, submit corrected documents and follow up with the Registry.
Key lesson: An incorrect respondent entry need not be fatal to an appeal.
Case 07: Failure to cure registry defects leads to threshold dismissal of Department’s appeal
In favour of Taxpayer | Appeal by Department
Citation
Pratibha Rai v. Parle Biscuits Private Limited
GSTAT Varanasi | 2026 (10) TMI 206
Appeal No.: APL/D17/VRN/2026 | Date: 29.09.2026
Facts
The State Tax Department, Varanasi, appealed against an order favouring Parle Biscuits Pvt. Ltd.
- FAA found the taxpayer bona fide, with minor discrepancies and no intent to evade tax.
- Tax and penalty in dispute were shown as below ₹2 lakh.
- The Department failed to cure Registry defects despite repeated opportunities.
Issue Involved
Can an appeal be dismissed for failure to cure Registry defects despite repeated opportunities?
Particularly where the appeal involves a small disputed amount and appears meritless.
Taxpayer Submissions
Counsel appeared virtually, but no specific arguments are recorded in the order.
Department’s Submissions
Officers appeared in person, but no specific arguments are recorded in the order.
Tribunal Analysis
Appeal dismissed at the threshold. The Tribunal noted:
- Repeated failure to cure Registry defects, which showed the appeal was filed only to abuse the Tribunal’s process.
- Tax and penalty in dispute shown as below ₹2 lakh.
- FAA’s findings of bona fides, minor discrepancies and no intent to evade tax.
The Tribunal considered the appeal meritless and further time unjustified.
Final Order
The Department’s appeal was dismissed.
The Tribunal held that granting further time to cure the defects would not serve the interests of justice.
Our Take
Registry defect memos are easy to park. Treat each one like a hearing date: diarise it, cure it fully and file a compliance note.
- Respondents may seek threshold dismissal based on uncured defects and weak merits.
- In Department appeals, examine Circular No. 207/1/2024-GST, which sets a ₹20 lakh monetary limit, and whether the State has adopted it.
Key lesson: Raise the monetary-limit objection where applicable, but do not rely on it alone.
Case 08: Clerical-error plea fails: reversal of CGST/SGST credit claimed instead of IGST upheld
In favour of Revenue | Appeal by Taxpayer
Citation
M/s. Tej Farm Services v. Shri Prakash Yadav, Joint Commissioner, State Tax, Headquarter Lucknow & Ors.
GSTAT Lucknow | 2026 (9) TMI 1081
Appeal No.: APL/10/LCK/2026 | Date: 14.09.2026
Facts
The dispute concerned an ITC mismatch for July 2017–March 2018.
- IGST credit of ₹63,480.18 was allowed by the FAA.
- CGST/SGST credit reversal of ₹3,72,121 was sustained.
- Tax, interest and penalty demand of ₹9,33,222 remained.
Issue Involved
Can ITC claimed under the wrong tax heads be retained as a clerical error?
The taxpayer claimed CGST/SGST credit in GSTR-3B, although the credit appeared under IGST in GSTR-2A.
Taxpayer Submissions
- The wrong tax-head claim was a clerical error.
- There was no revenue loss or intent to evade tax.
- Section 73, interest and penalty should not apply.
Relied on: Rejimon Padickapparambil Alex and Padiken Silks (Kerala HC).
Department’s Submissions
- ITC must be claimed under the correct tax head.
- A shortfall under one head must be discharged under that head.
- Excess payment or credit elsewhere must be addressed through remedies permitted by law.
Tribunal Analysis
The FAA’s order was upheld.
- IGST credit of ₹63,480.18 was allowed.
- CGST/SGST credit reversal of ₹3,72,121, with interest and penalty, was sustained.
- The appellant produced no new facts or records warranting interference.
- The cited Kerala HC precedents were held factually different and of no help.
Final Order
The appeal is dismissed and the order of the first appeal is confirmed.
Our Take
A clerical-error plea is only as strong as the reconciliation behind it. Put the GSTR-2A, GSTR-3B and ledger working on record at the first appeal itself.
- Ensure cited judgments are factually relevant.
- Revenue neutrality alone will not erase tax, interest or penalty. On interest, test the combined ledger balance (cf. Circular 192/04/2023-GST).
Key lesson: A plea may fail when supporting evidence is missing, even where a technical error is alleged.
Case 09: Sec 129 penalty set aside: no hearing, beyond SCN, no evasion proved
In favour of Taxpayer | Appeal by Taxpayer
Citation
Shilchar Technologies Limited v. The Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Karnataka, Bangalore & Ors.
GSTAT Bengaluru | 2026 (10) TMI 702
Appeal No.: APL/219/BUR/2026 | Date: 08.10.2026
Facts
Shilchar moved 114 drums of transformer oil from Gujarat to Tamil Nadu under a delivery challan and e-way bill.
- The oil related to seven earlier invoices on which IGST was paid.
- The challan described one transformer; the e-way bill showed 110 drums.
- MOV-07 proposed ₹2,87,595, but MOV-09 imposed ₹5,75,190 on the same day.
Issues Involved
- Did MOV-09 violate natural justice, and did the penalty exceed the notice in breach of Section 75(7)?
- Did non-compliance with Circular 41/15/2018-GST invalidate the order?
- Was the Section 129(1)(a) penalty justified?
Taxpayer Submissions
- Oil was part of an already-taxed supply; mismatch was clerical.
- MOV-09 preceded the reply and hearing; its penalty exceeded MOV-07.
Department’s Submissions
- Transit documents had material discrepancies.
- Non-upload was procedural; MOV-07 amount was a clerical error.
Tribunal Analysis
The order violated natural justice.
- MOV-09 was passed before the reply and hearing, repeating the notice without application of mind.
- Section 75(7): the penalty cannot exceed the notice. No clerical-error exception applies.
Documentation discrepancies did not establish evasion.
- Challan and PO linked the oil to seven earlier invoices; batch movement under Rule 55(5) was allowed.
- Rule 55(5) does not require the original invoice to be produced before the officer.
- Non-upload of MOV-09 was a technical lapse, not a ground on its own to invalidate the order.
Final Order
The appeal is allowed. The order-in-appeal dated 23.03.2023 is set aside with consequential relief.
Our Take
Same-day MOV-07 and MOV-09 orders are more common than they should be. Reply in writing, ask for the hearing in writing and keep the acknowledgement.
- Compare the penalty with the notice under Section 75(7); Circular 258/04/2026-GST stresses the same.
- Keep challans and e-way bills consistent, linking batch movements to earlier invoices.
Key lesson: Accurate documentation and procedural compliance can prevent avoidable detention disputes.
Case 10: GST not leviable on assignment of GIDC leasehold rights: Tribunal follows binding Gujarat HC ruling
In favour of Taxpayer | Appeal by Department
Citation
Assistant Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Division-IX, Ankleshwar, Vadodara-II v. Pragna Chemical Industries, Shivabhishek Industrial Park Pvt. Ltd. & Kumar Packaging
GSTAT Surat | 2026 (10) TMI 619
Appeal Nos. APL/59/SRT/2026, APL/82/SRT/2026 and APL/83/SRT/2026 | Date: 06.10.2026
Facts
- GST was demanded under RCM on the assignment of GIDC leasehold rights, for consideration, to third-party assignees.
- The Appellate Authority set aside the demands, following the Gujarat HC ruling in Gujarat Chamber of Commerce and Industry v. UOI. The Department appealed.
Issue Involved
Is GST payable on the assignment of GIDC leasehold rights for consideration?
The key question was whether transferring leasehold rights in land and buildings to third-party assignees constitutes a taxable supply under GST.
Taxpayer Submissions
The case is squarely covered by Gujarat Chamber of Commerce, which is binding.
Department’s Submission
The appeals were filed because the Department had filed an SLP against Gujarat Chamber of Commerce. The SLPs have since been dismissed, but the Department is in the process of filing a review petition.
Tribunal Analysis
Assignment of leasehold rights was held outside GST supply.
- The Gujarat HC held that such a transfer is a transfer of benefits arising from immovable property.
- The Bombay HC agreed in Aerocom Cushions, and the Supreme Court dismissed the Department’s SLPs against both rulings.
Final Order
GST is not leviable on the transactions. The questions of Sections 74 and 122(2)(b), and whether RCM applies, do not survive. The Department’s appeals are dismissed.
Our Take
Check the status of a High Court ruling on the day of the hearing, not just when drafting. An SLP or review can change the position within weeks.
- A jurisdictional High Court ruling binds the Tribunal unless stayed or recalled.
- A proposed review petition does not, by itself, remove that binding effect.
- Verify the cause title when citing; the portal cannot correct it (see also Case 06).
Key lesson: Once the SC dismisses the SLP, a pending review is no ground to ignore the High Court ruling.
Download this edition
Weighed on the SCALE. Settled by the GAVEL. See you next week in Docket #03.
Read all editions of GSTAT Docket
More from our blog
[Web team: add links to 3 related GGSH blog posts here]
This summary is for general information only and is based on the orders as published. Readers should refer to the full text of each order before relying on it.
