GGSH’s Weekly GSTAT Docket #03 | 20 Nov 2026

GSTAT Docket #03: when your annual return (GSTR-9/9C) reaches the Tribunal

Every week, GSTAT Docket brings you five GST Appellate Tribunal decisions from benches across India: properly cited, simplified, with who appealed, who won, and our take on what each one changes for your next appeal. With the FY 2025-26 annual return due on 31 December 2026 and the 30 November cut-off for ITC and credit notes days away, this edition looks at disputes that began in GSTR-9 and GSTR-9C: late credit notes, carry-forward errors, a discount entry in Column 5(O), a GSTR-9 vs 9C gap and an exemption that could not be proved State by State.

Our GAVEL picks this week

  • Wrong carry-forward in GSTR-9? The ITC stays. → Case 12
  • Exempt turnover in 9C? Prove it, GSTIN by GSTIN. → Case 15

Inside this edition

  1. Late credit notes can’t reduce refund turnover (Partly in favour of Taxpayer)
  2. GSTR-9/9C errors can’t cancel ITC availed in GSTR-3B (In favour of Taxpayer)
  3. 9C discount entry alone isn’t an output-tax demand (Remanded)
  4. GSTR-9 vs 9C gap isn’t unpaid tax; Rule 42 needs segregation (Remanded)
  5. Exempt interest claim fails without State-wise proof (In favour of Revenue)

Case 11: Time-barred credit notes can’t reduce turnover in an inverted-duty refund

Partly in favour of Taxpayer | Appeal by Department

Citation

The Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise, Siliguri Commissionerate v. M/s Rajshahi Banijya Private Limited
GSTAT Kolkata | 2026 (10) TMI 623
Appeal No.: APL/18/KLK/2026 | Date: 07.10.2026

Facts

A tea supplier (HSN 0902, 5%) claimed an inverted-duty refund of ₹4,32,537 for April–June 2021.

  • The refund was sanctioned, and the FAA rejected the Department’s appeal.
  • Credit notes of ₹12,04,575 issued in the period were excluded from Adjusted Total Turnover.
  • The Department appealed on this one ground.

Issue Involved

Can credit notes for an earlier year, issued after the Section 34 time limit, reduce Adjusted Total Turnover under Rule 89(5)?

Taxpayer Submissions

  • Once a credit note is issued and disclosed under Section 34, taxable value stands reduced.
  • Ignoring credit notes would artificially inflate turnover.

Department’s Submissions

  • The credit notes were not linked to refund-period invoices.
  • They related to unspecified invoices of earlier periods.

Tribunal Analysis

Valid credit notes reduce turnover; late ones do not.

  • The CA certificate matched GSTR-1 for April, May and June 2021.
  • Credit notes of ₹11,03,065 related to refund-period invoices and were rightly excluded.
  • Three credit notes of ₹1,01,510, dated June 2021, related to FY 2019-20 invoices, beyond the Section 34(2) time limit.
  • Adding them back, turnover became ₹5,95,52,703 and the refund ₹4,30,073 under Rule 89(5).

Final Order

The Department’s appeal was dismissed with modification. The refund was restricted to ₹4,30,073, and the excess ₹2,464 is recoverable.

Our Take

The Section 34 clock runs on the supply’s financial year, not the date the credit note is raised. For FY 2025-26 supplies, that is 30 Nov 2026 or the GSTR-9 filing date, if earlier.

  • A certificate matched to GSTR-1, with invoice-wise linkage, carried the day here.
  • Late credit notes don’t just lose the tax adjustment; they can also cut refunds.

Key lesson: Only credit notes issued within the Section 34 time limit can reduce turnover, for tax or for refunds.


Case 12: GSTR-9/9C reporting errors can’t cancel ITC already availed in GSTR-3B

In favour of Taxpayer | Appeal by Taxpayer

Citation

Anil Kumar Mohindru, M/s Three Aces Global Logistics Pvt. Ltd. v. Shri Prakash Yadav, Joint Commissioner (IT), State Tax, Lucknow
GSTAT Ghaziabad | 2026 (10) TMI 73
Appeal No.: APL/6/GZB/2026 | Date: 29.09.2026

Facts

ITC of ₹20,94,605 for FY 2018-19 was taken in GSTR-3B in Oct 2019–Mar 2020 (late supplier invoices).

  • The AA found the supplies genuine but denied this ITC under Section 16(4): demand ₹32,46,638.
  • The FAA upheld it, adding GSTR-9/9C non-disclosure and Section 16(2)(b)/(c) grounds.

Issues Involved

  1. Can an error in GSTR-9/9C defeat ITC already availed in GSTR-3B?
  2. Can grounds not in the SCN be added at the appellate stage?
  3. Is the credit protected by retrospective Section 16(5)?

Taxpayer Submissions

  • GSTR-9/9C are not Section 39 returns; they don’t decide entitlement.
  • New grounds at appeal breach Section 75(7).

Department’s Submissions

  • Section 16(5) doesn’t validate a wrong GSTR-9/9C declaration.
  • Section 16(2) conditions remain; a certificate under Circular 183 was required.

Tribunal Analysis

Availment, utilisation and annual reconciliation are distinct events.

  • GSTR-9/9C are reporting tools, not the return through which ITC is taken.
  • A reconciliation error may prompt verification, but cannot extinguish credit availed.
  • Grounds outside the SCN cannot sustain the demand (Section 75(7)).

Section 16(5) protects the credit.

  • GSTR-3B is a Section 39 return (Bharti Airtel), filed before 30.11.2021; Circular 237 applies to pending appeals.

Final Order

The appeal is allowed. The IGST demand of ₹20,94,605, related interest and ₹2,09,461 penalty are set aside.

Our Take

Read past the 16(5) headline. The real point is how the Tribunal treats the annual return: GSTR-9/9C report the year, they don’t decide entitlement.

  • Still fill Tables 8C, 13 of GSTR-9 and 12C of 9C correctly; a wrong carry-forward invites a notice.
  • Check the first appellate order for grounds outside the SCN, and invoke Section 75(7).

Key lesson: A reporting error in the annual return is a reason to verify, not to deny credit.


Case 13: GSTR-9C discount entry alone can’t create an output-tax demand

Remanded | Appeal by Department

Citation

Satyendra Kumar Singh v. Peoples Honda
GSTAT Agra | 2026 (10) TMI 1628
Appeal No.: APL/14/AGR/2026 | Date: 16.10.2026

Facts

A two-wheeler dealer showed ₹14,19,144 in Column 5(O) of GSTR-9C for FY 2017-18: discounts and incentives from Honda.

  • It cited a DRC-03 deposit already relied on in an earlier appeal.
  • Section 74 order: tax ₹2,55,446, equal penalty and interest ₹3,43,403. The FAA ruled for the dealer.

Issues Involved

  1. Can a Column 5(O) disclosure in GSTR-9C, by itself, justify output tax on the recipient?
  2. Can the Revenue recast the discounts as marketing services at the appellate stage?

Taxpayer Submissions

  • The DRC-03 reference was inadvertent, in the early GST period.
  • Discounts arose under a pre-existing agreement; no suppression.

Department’s Submissions

  • Section 15(3) conditions were not verified; the deposit was used twice.
  • Target-linked incentives are consideration for promotion services.

Tribunal Analysis

Section 15(3) governs the supplier’s value, not the recipient’s turnover.

  • Receiving a discount does not let the dealer reduce its own outward turnover.
  • If the dealer did not actually reduce turnover or tax in GSTR-1/3B, a 9C disclosure alone cannot justify output tax.
  • If the supplier did not reduce its taxable value, no ITC reversal arises.
  • The marketing-services theory was not in the SCN and was rejected.

Final Order

Both orders are set aside and the matter is remanded to verify the supplier’s credit notes, the agreement and invoice linkage, and the return treatment, within the existing SCN.

Our Take

Column 5(O) of GSTR-9C is a catch-all. An amount parked there without explanation invites a notice.

  • Explain every reconciling item in 9C, with its nature and return treatment.
  • From 01.11.2026, no prior agreement is needed: a Section 34 credit note plus the buyer’s ITC reversal will do (see Case 01).

Key lesson: A reconciliation disclosure is not a tax liability unless the returns actually reduced tax.


Case 14: GSTR-9 vs 9C difference is not unpaid tax: ₹56.24 lakh demand remanded

Remanded | Appeal by Taxpayer

Citation

Nitin Bakers Private Limited v. Vijay Singh Visen, Deputy Commissioner, Kanpur & Ors.
GSTAT Lucknow | 2026 (10) TMI 1629
Appeal No.: APL/108/LCK/2026 | Date: 21.10.2026

Facts

A bakery maker’s FY 2018-19 returns were scrutinised. Turnover ₹5.97 crore, of which ₹5.59 crore was exempt.

  • SCN: excess ITC ₹2,589.62 (3B vs 2A); ₹25,93,217 gap between Table 9 of GSTR-9 and Table 9P of 9C; short Rule 42/43 reversal ₹51,756.66.
  • Ex parte demand of ₹56,24,458; the first appeal was also dismissed ex parte.

Issue Involved

Can a demand rest on return-to-return differences without reconciling the underlying records?

Taxpayer Submissions

  • ITC reversed in GSTR-3B was ignored.
  • Tables 9 and 9P measure different things, as explained in Table 10 of 9C.
  • ITC reversed (₹29,48,853) far exceeded the alleged shortfall.

Department’s Submissions

  • No documents were filed despite four hearings.
  • Without a specific/common split, the officer had to rely on portal data.

Tribunal Analysis

Portal comparisons cannot decide tax.

  • Reversals in Table 4(B) of GSTR-3B exceeded the credit availed; the net ITC position was never checked.
  • The 9 vs 9P gap reflected ITC reversals and needed verification of ledgers and invoices.
  • The Rule 42/43 demand treated the entire ITC as common credit, without segregation.
  • The orders showed a “total lack of factual verification and non-application of mind”.

Final Order

Both orders are set aside and the matter is remanded for fresh adjudication. The appellant must submit all documents needed for verification.

Our Take

Ex parte at two levels and still a remand, but only because the returns themselves showed the reversals. Don’t count on that.

  • Reply to ASMT-10 with the reconciliation itself, not just a cover letter.
  • Keep a Rule 42/43 working that separates specific and common credit.

Key lesson: A return mismatch is a question to verify, not proof of short payment.


Case 15: Exempt interest claim fails without State-wise proof of unreconciled 9C turnover

In favour of Revenue | Appeal by Taxpayer

Citation

Jana Small Finance Bank Limited v. Shri Pushpendra Kumar Meena, Commissioner (State GST), Chhattisgarh
GSTAT Raipur | 2026 (9) TMI 1655
Appeal No.: APL/30/RPR/2026 | Date: 22.09.2026

Facts

For FY 2017-18, the demand arose from unreconciled taxable turnover in Table 7G of GSTR-9C.

  • Turnover of ₹3,51,68,888 was taxed at 18%: CGST and SGST ₹31,65,020 each, with interest and penalty.
  • The bank said ₹3,51,62,835 was exempt interest (NPA clawback, securitisation and other reversals) of other States, wrongly reported in Chhattisgarh.

Issues Involved

  1. Is interest on loans exempt under Entry 27 of Notification 12/2017-CT(R)?
  2. Did the bank prove the disputed turnover was exempt interest of other States?

Taxpayer Submissions

  • Interest is exempt; the reply and hearing were ignored.
  • Audit is at PAN-India level, so a State split is not possible.
  • A CA certificate was filed.

Department’s Submissions

  • The reversals are book entries, not interest consideration.
  • They were not linked to borrower accounts or the Chhattisgarh registration.

Tribunal Analysis

Exempt in principle, but the claim must be proved.

  • Entry 27 exempts interest on loans: decided in favour of the bank.
  • The claimant must give transaction-specific, State-specific evidence; filing 9C doesn’t dispense with it.
  • The certificate did not state what was verified or on what documentary basis.
  • Evidence that could be produced was withheld, so an adverse inference followed.

Final Order

The appeal is rejected. Procedural lapses, even if established, would not have changed the outcome.

Our Take

For multi-State entities, each GSTIN’s annual return has to stand on its own numbers. Entity-level audit figures won’t carry a State-level claim.

  • Keep GSTIN-wise working for exempt turnover, linked to accounts or invoices.
  • A certificate carries weight when it states what was verified and how (see Case 11).

Key lesson: Whoever claims an exemption must prove the figures, GSTIN by GSTIN.


Download this edition

GSTAT Docket #03 (PDF)

Weighed on the SCALE. Settled by the GAVEL. See you next week in Docket #04.

Read all editions of GSTAT Docket

More from our blog

[Web team: add links to 3 related GGSH blog posts here]

This summary is for general information only and is based on the orders as published. Readers should refer to the full text of each order before relying on it.

Author

CA Saradha Hariharan

Co-Founder Partner | Head of Indirect Tax Advisory GGSH & Co. LLP

Avatar photo
Written By

Co-Founder Partner | Head of Indirect Tax Advisory GGSH & Co. LLP

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.