A taxpayer who succeeds in the first appeal may still receive a notice that the department has challenged the order before GSTAT. This is why a favourable order should be monitored until the relevant appeal period and proceedings have been dealt with.

Understanding the legal framework

Section 112(3) provides the department’s route to seek a Tribunal determination on specified points. If a departmental appeal is filed, the taxpayer should read the notice and appeal grounds carefully. The department may be challenging a part of the order that the taxpayer considered settled.

Section 112(5) provides for a memorandum of cross-objections by the respondent in the appeal, within the period specified by the provision after receiving notice of the appeal. The Tribunal may permit a further period where sufficient cause is shown, subject to the statutory framework. The GSTAT portal identifies Form GST APL-06 for cross-objections.

Practical considerations

A cross-objection is not simply a reply letter. It should identify the relevant parts of the order, the points being contested and the relief sought. It may be strategically important where the taxpayer wants to challenge findings or portions of the order while defending the result on other grounds.

Registering on the GSTAT portal, maintaining updated contact details and monitoring communications can help avoid missing a short response window. Once a departmental appeal notice is received, obtain professional advice quickly and diarise the deadline.

Frequently Asked Questions

What form is used for GSTAT cross-objections?

The GSTAT portal identifies Form GST APL-06 for filing cross-objections.

Does a favourable first appeal mean the department cannot challenge it? No. The department has a statutory route to appeal in the circumstances set out in Section 112(3).

Watch the related video

Day 21 video: [GSTAT DAY 21]

Author

CA Saradha Hariharan

Co-Founder Partner | Head of Indirect Tax Advisory GGSH & Co. LLP

Avatar photo
Written By

Co-Founder Partner | Head of Indirect Tax Advisory GGSH & Co. LLP

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is required.

This field is required.